blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | Since I Fell For You | 1945 |  |
| Buddy Johnson And His Orchestra with Ella Johnson |
| 2 | Since I Fell For You | 1947 | |
| Annie Laurie With Paul Gayten And His Trio |
| 3 | Since I Fell For You | 1947 | |
| Dinah Washington And Rudy Martin Trio |
| 4 | Since I Fell For You | 2 | Dec 1963 | |
| Lenny Welch |
| 5 | Since I Fell For You | Mar 1966 | |
| Odessa Harris |
| 6 | Theme (The Good Old Songs), Oh Donna, Since I Fell For You, I Miss You So, So This Is Love, Goodnight My Love | Aug 1970 | |
| The Vogues |
| 7 | Since I Fell For You | Sep 1970 | |
| Mavis Staples |
| 8 | Since I Fell For You | Dec 1970 | |
| The Persuasions |
| 9 | Since I Fell For You | Mar 1972 | |
| Laura Lee |
| 10 | Since I Fell For You | Feb 1976 | |
| Charlie Rich |
| 11 | Since I Fell For You, I'm Falling In Love | Jul 1977 | |
| Hodges, James And Smith |
| 12 | Since I Fell For You | Jul 1979 | |
| Con Hunley |
| 13 | Since I Fell For You | Oct 1987 | |
| Al Jarreau |
| 14 | Since I Fell For You | Apr 2012 | |
| Nicole Henry Featuring Kirk Whalum |