blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | Am I That Easy To Forget | May 1959 |  |
| Carl Belew |
| 2 | Am I That Easy To Forget | Mar 1960 | |
| Debbie Reynolds with Billy Vaughn Orchestra |
| 3 | Am I That Easy To Forget? | Apr 1960 | |
| Skeeter Davis |
| 4 | Am I That Easy To Forget | Feb 1963 | |
| Little Esther Phillips |
| 5 | Am I That Easy To Forget | 16 | Jan 1968 | |
| Engelbert Humperdinck |
| 6 | Am I That Easy To Forget | Aug 1973 | |
| Jim Reeves with The Jordanaires |